Shady Ladies of the Klondike – Legends of America
The Klondike Gold Rush, a frenzied stampede of prospectors to the Yukon region of Canada in the late 1890s, conjures images of rugged men braving harsh conditions in pursuit of fortune. However, the gold rush era was not solely defined by male adventurers. A significant, albeit often overlooked, segment of the population consisted of women, many of whom navigated the treacherous landscape of boomtowns as saloon girls and prostitutes. These "shady ladies," as they were often called, played a complex and multifaceted role in the social and economic fabric of the Klondike, leaving behind a legacy that continues to fascinate and intrigue.
The Allure of the Klondike:
The discovery of gold in the Klondike region of Yukon Territory in 1896 ignited a global frenzy. Thousands of individuals, driven by dreams of instant wealth, flocked to the remote and unforgiving territory. This influx of humanity transformed sleepy settlements into bustling boomtowns, characterized by rampant speculation, lawlessness, and a palpable sense of opportunity. Skagway and Dyea in Alaska, along with Dawson City in Canada, emerged as the primary hubs for gold seekers, each grappling with the challenges and temptations that accompanied rapid growth.
Diverse Backgrounds, Limited Choices:
The women who found themselves working as prostitutes in these boomtowns hailed from diverse backgrounds. Some were drawn by the promise of financial independence, recognizing the potential to capitalize on the influx of miners flush with cash. Others were victims of circumstance, forced into the profession by abduction, abandonment, or the death of their husbands or family members. With limited opportunities available to women in the late 19th century, prostitution often became the only viable means of survival in these harsh and unforgiving environments.
The Story of Ella D. Wilson:
One such woman was Ella D. Wilson, an African American prostitute working in Skagway. Her life was tragically cut short in May 1898 when she was found murdered in her bed. The circumstances surrounding her death paint a grim picture of the dangers faced by women in the Klondike. Ella was discovered with a pillowcase over her head, a gag in her mouth, and her wrists and ankles bound. Her money and jewelry were missing, and her belongings had been ransacked, suggesting a robbery gone awry.
Rumors circulated that Ella had amassed a considerable sum of money, approximately $2,000, which would be equivalent to over $60,000 today. Mattie Silks, a well-known madam from Denver, Colorado, who had spent time in Skagway, accused the notorious con man Jeff "Soapy" Smith of being responsible for Ella’s death. However, in the lawless atmosphere of Skagway, these accusations never led to any formal charges. Just five weeks later, Soapy Smith himself was killed in a shootout. The murder of Ella D. Wilson remains unsolved to this day, a stark reminder of the perils faced by women in the Klondike.
Ella’s final resting place is in the Gold Rush Cemetery in Skagway, not far from the grave of Soapy Smith, the man accused of her murder. Her grave serves as a poignant reminder of the lives lost and the injustices suffered during the Klondike Gold Rush.
Ruth Brown and Rose Arnold: Entrepreneurs of the Evening:
Two other African American women, Ruth Brown and Rose Arnold, also worked as prostitutes in Skagway. They recognized a unique opportunity when Company L of the 24th Infantry, one of four all-black units in the United States Army, was stationed in the town. After hearing of a white prostitute refusing service to a black soldier, Ruth and Rose established their house of ill repute on Sixth Avenue, conveniently located next door to the Company L barracks. This strategic location provided them with a steady stream of customers and a thriving business.
However, their fortunes changed when the soldiers were transferred in 1902. With the departure of their primary clientele, Ruth and Rose found themselves in a less profitable business environment.
Defiance in the Courtroom:
By 1905, Skagway was under the rule of Magistrate Tanner, who oversaw the town’s gamblers, prostitutes, and saloon owners. Prostitution was still prevalent, but it was heavily regulated through quarterly fines. Women in the sex industry typically pleaded guilty and paid a fine of $25, plus court fees, which amounted to approximately $700 in today’s money. This meant that each woman paid nearly $3,000 annually to stay in business.
On January 25, 1905, Ruth and Rose decided to challenge the system. When they appeared before Magistrate Tanner, they both pleaded not guilty to "being an inmate of a house of ill-repute." This bold move surprised everyone, including Ruth and Rose themselves. Rose Arnold was acquitted of the charge, and Ruth Brown tied up the court for several days fighting the charge of "keeping a house of ill repute in connection with Rose Arnold."
Ultimately, Magistrate Tanner managed to secure a conviction. On January 29, Ruth Brown was found guilty and received the standard $25 fine plus court costs, totaling $141, which would be over $4,000 today. The message was clear: Skagway would prosecute prostitutes to the fullest extent of the law, and stunts like Ruth Brown’s would not be tolerated.
In early February, Ruth and Rose decided to cut their losses and leave Skagway for good, heading to Juneau, Alaska. After their departure, they disappeared from the public record, their fate unknown.
Diamond Lil Davenport: The Vaudeville Star Turned Madam:
Not all women in the Klondike experienced hardship and tragedy. Diamond Lil Davenport, a former Vaudeville star, arrived in Alaska with her troupe and decided to stay, opening the most luxurious brothel in Skagway. Described as a woman of exceptional beauty and refinement, Diamond Lil achieved considerable success in Alaska before moving on to Seattle, Washington. Her story represents a different facet of the Klondike experience, one of entrepreneurial success and social mobility.
Conclusion:
The "shady ladies" of the Klondike were a diverse group of women who played a significant role in the history of the gold rush era. While their profession was often stigmatized and their lives fraught with danger, they were also resourceful, resilient, and, in some cases, successful entrepreneurs. Their stories offer a glimpse into the complex social and economic dynamics of the Klondike boomtowns and challenge the traditional narrative of the gold rush as a purely male-dominated endeavor. The tales of Ella D. Wilson, Ruth Brown, Rose Arnold, and Diamond Lil Davenport serve as a reminder of the diverse experiences of women in the Klondike and their enduring legacy in the history of the American West.
Also See:
- Diamond Lil Davenport – Madam of Skagway, Alaska
- Leading Madams of the Old West
- Painted Ladies of the Old West
- Women of the Klondike Gold Rush
Sources: